Shopping cart is empty.

Birchbark Blog

Everything You Know About Indians Is Wrong

Louise Erdrich - Monday, October 19, 2009
Everything You Know about Indians Is Wrong, a satisfyingly complex book by Paul Chaat Smith, who maintains that although we are considered somehow primitive and simple we are actually oceans of terrifying complexity.  I have been called this by men, with no regard to my Turtle Mountain heritage.  Just . . . an ocean of complexity.  And this book, too, is so complicated that I found my emotions were all mixed up.  Irony, laughter, rage, weariness.  A mixture -- a complex character trait but as one of my character flaws is a vague obscurity I appreciated the harsh wit and intelligence in these essays.  A recommendation with many stars after it.

I'll be taking this book along on my next trip along with Chitra Divarakuni's One Amazing Thing, covering Indians -- East to West.

And some favorite post snow fall reading -- Homer and Langely, by E.L.Doctorow.  I loved this novel for its quirky, mild mannered fidelity, for its courtly reserve, and at last for the gentle horror of its ending.  I thought it beautifully imagined and restrained.  A perfect work.  The portrait of a consciousness cut off from even the world of music, floating in soundless space, the last 10 pages were extraordinarily moving to me.

Axsel Bjorklund commented on 22-Oct-2009 08:28 AM
On the one hand, not having read the same books, I hesitate to comment. On the other hand, under the guiding principle of "fools rush in...", I must say that simplicity and complexity are two sides of the same coin. Recently, scientists have progressed from Chaos Theory to a theory of complexity where there is what they term a "self-organizing principle". This leads me to believe that you, me, or anybody else that is hassling with this framed in terms of a problem can henceforth rest easy. In short, everything will be OK.
Gary Deason commented on 31-Oct-2009 02:51 PM
CULTURE: We Anglos value our complex world of science-technology-economics-business, but remain pretty simplistic, even naïve, about the equally complex world of spirit-religion-land-art-culture-family-human relationships. Anglos misunderstand and devalue Indians by reducing their expectations to what they themselves cherish and practice (technology, business, etc) instead of what Indians cherish and practice(spirituality, family, etc). We all see through our own lenses. Measured by the standards of white culture, not surprisingly, Indian cultures come up short. If one reverses the viewpoint, Anglos come up equally short, probably even shorter.

RELATIONSHIPS: Maybe this is part of the larger social and cultural background (there’s also the genetic) of male-female relationships, particularly a (white) male attitude toward a woman of native heritage living her uncommonly rich spiritual, cross-cultural, and family background. Static, linear, deductive heads and hearts struggle to understand and appreciate kinetic, relational, value-laden thoughts and emotions. The reverse is true too.

UPSHOT: If inter-cultural relations and male-female relations were more like Yin-Yang or Same-Other, with a healthy dose of respect maintaining equilibrium, the tension would power compelling outcomes.

Hmmm... that turned out too cerebral. The important point is: I hope we all keep trying on both fronts!
Barbara Scott Zeller commented on 20-Nov-2009 09:13 AM
I am an Anglo who does not recognize herself in Gary's post, so "We Anglos" may be a stretch. Cultural generalities scare me.
Post a Comment!

Canoe Family

Recent PostsRSS


adventure italy ireland More Remarkable Trees pilgrims Population British Navy Jim Harrison Gary Clement buffalo Collective Denial The Royal Prussian Library thank you friends Bill Moyers Journal coyote health care reform city of books ptsd Book Review School Gardens trees green Wastepaper World on the Edge Anton Treuer Rare Books Love Gryphon Press Light in August Catalyst Too Loud A Solitude Vic Glover Beth Dooley Roberto Bolano Wendy Makoons Geniusz Bleak House Greenland The Birchbark House thanks The Wealth of Nature Tree Houses National Book Award Education cafe Magers and Quinn Too Much Happiness The Blue Sky S.C. Gwynne Native Arts joy Michael Jackson Ojibwe birchbark house series The Porcupine Year Empire of the Summer Moon H2Oil Islam bill mckibben Minnesota Philip Roth spring graphix Bohumil Hrabal Pembina friends Chickadee Alice Munro Emily Johnson post holiday reads ependent mississippi 2666 Zombies Poetry The Ojibwe Interview Mohamed's Ghosts Gail Caldwell The Resilient Gardener Crushing Books photography This Green World Makoons monkey in a dryer Kabul how good looking you are devoted customers Ha Jin Tar Sands Unnatural Disasters aquifer germany japan Nemesis china gardens Up Late Again plants Victory Gardens local economy language revitalization Louise Guthrie Theater Minneapolis Peak Water Brown Dog Mankato Powwow book and dinner club The Transition Handbook Master Butchers Singing Club Remarkable Trees E.L. Doctorow Climate Change twins Fireworks Our Knowledge Is Not Primitive Ojibwemowin Hilary Mantel anniversary support Afghanistan leaves and snow Anishinabe Let's Take the Long Way Home Kate DiCamillo William Trevor Small Bookstores as Commons Keystone XL Nero peculiar touches of green and gold Women and Trees Video france Birchbark Books boarding school gratitude Czech Writer The Game of Silence the most romantic city in the world The Farmer's Daughter Alan Weisman fresh water customers Chitra Divakaruni Kenwood Gardens President Obama Dogs euphoria Anishinabemowin cafe closing Wolf Hall State Troopers favorite tree Ice post holiday Aza neighborhood Keeping Heart on Pine Ridge knowledge Easter Island Native People Stephen Salisbury solstice, Thomas King incarnation Canada NACDI:All My Relations Aubrey/Maturin Dartmouth favorite book sweden favorite dog Hillary Clinton Keepers of the Trees Green Team Peak Oil north dakota show your love Patrick O'Brian tree books Botany The Round House Milkweed Press