Shopping cart is empty.

Birchbark Blog

Things I Didn't Know

Louise Erdrich - Friday, December 12, 2014

Last August we were sorting through the advanced readers copies that had collected on the bookstore shelves. My daughter Pallas picked up The Underground Girls of Kabul by Jenny Nordberg. I thought I'd seen the last of that book, but Pallas came back for Christmas and put that reading copy in my hands. She told me to read it, I did, and now I have to say to you. READ THIS. The Underground Girls of Kabul is subtitled: In Search of a Hidden Resistance in Afghanistan. This book. If you read it, you will never forget Azita, Mehran, Zahra, Shukria, or Shahed -- all women who have been raised as boys in Afghanistan -- and then forced to return to being women. Nordberg explores a cultural practice that astonished me. It makes sense -- to "make" a girl at birth into a boy, for at least part of her life, is to give her a taste of what it is to be human. To have a will. Often, it is a magical practice that will supposedly prompt a woman's body to produce a male. Most hauntingly, one of these women became a "brother" to a real brother in order to protect him from possible poisoning by a previous wife in a polygamous marriage. She ate everything and drank everything before her brother. You will not stop reading this book until you find out what happens to these women -- what is happening to them now.

Karima Bennoune, a professor of international law at UC-Davis, grew up in Algeria. Her impassioned and superbly intelligent book, Your Fatwa Does Not Apply Here, begins with this sentence: "Could I defend my father from the Armed Islamic Group with a paring knife?"  Bennoune's father, Mahfoud Bennoune, taught Darwinism and was a fearless critic of armed fundamentalists like the Islamic Salvation Front, who sponsored assassinations of of Bennoune's fellow professors. Her experience impelled Karima Bennoune to travel the world, at great personal risk, in order to interview moderate Muslim people, often women, who cogently and steadfastly insist on human rights in violently fundamentalist settings. She has described herself (I was lucky enough to meet her) as "the woman who makes people cry" because these stories about people who strive to maintain humanity, who die for the right to dissent, to speak freely, become educated, dance, write, paint, sing, bare their faces to the wind, their hair to the sky, and who insist that the memory of those killed in this struggle not be erased, these stories include unbearable loss. Yet the stubborn will to resist is mesmerizing -- I could not stop reading this book until page 195 (the hardcover). In the middle of this page, I had to set the book down in order to cry, too, along with the people whose existence gave me a sense of human grandeur. 

Canoe Family

Recent PostsRSS


favorite dog Vic Glover monkey in a dryer Dartmouth Brown Dog the most romantic city in the world buffalo Collective Denial Ice The Birchbark House thanks Native Arts Too Much Happiness Kabul Nero adventure Chickadee customers Alice Munro favorite tree joy Alan Weisman fresh water sweden Afghanistan Pembina aquifer germany Beth Dooley solstice, Thomas King euphoria President Obama Gary Clement Hillary Clinton Dogs devoted customers Jim Harrison Mohamed's Ghosts The Wealth of Nature post holiday Native People Our Knowledge Is Not Primitive post holiday reads ependent cafe closing bill mckibben Czech Writer Rare Books italy Philip Roth language revitalization Crushing Books Easter Island Empire of the Summer Moon pilgrims gratitude Wolf Hall Ojibwemowin Love Islam spring Makoons Catalyst The Royal Prussian Library Small Bookstores as Commons ireland This Green World Poetry The Farmer's Daughter Book Review The Blue Sky Women and Trees Mankato Powwow Too Loud A Solitude city of books Up Late Again The Transition Handbook france Louise plants local economy Wendy Makoons Geniusz boarding school Anton Treuer British Navy Chitra Divakaruni Keeping Heart on Pine Ridge green Hilary Mantel Aza anniversary health care reform The Porcupine Year north dakota tree books National Book Award incarnation photography birchbark house series Unnatural Disasters Aubrey/Maturin Gail Caldwell Nemesis china Roberto Bolano Bill Moyers Journal The Ojibwe thank you friends S.C. Gwynne Ha Jin Video Kate DiCamillo neighborhood Population Tar Sands Bleak House Tree Houses peculiar touches of green and gold Interview mississippi twins japan Let's Take the Long Way Home Bohumil Hrabal show your love Peak Water Victory Gardens Wastepaper H2Oil Fireworks Light in August friends Education Greenland support Gryphon Press coyote Minneapolis Botany Michael Jackson Anishinabemowin trees Climate Change Stephen Salisbury how good looking you are School Gardens Magers and Quinn Anishinabe graphix Peak Oil Kenwood Gardens State Troopers The Resilient Gardener ptsd leaves and snow Zombies book and dinner club World on the Edge Green Team Ojibwe E.L. Doctorow cafe NACDI:All My Relations 2666 gardens Minnesota Remarkable Trees Keepers of the Trees Birchbark Books Emily Johnson Milkweed Press Patrick O'Brian The Game of Silence More Remarkable Trees Keystone XL favorite book knowledge William Trevor Canada